I'll be reviewing the Browns' win in Cincinnati later, as the bigger news came on "Black Monday" with the Cleveland Browns
firing head coach
Kevin Stefanski and deciding to keep general manager Andrew Berry.
Stefanski, as has been noted ad nauseam, won two Coach of the Year awards and took the Browns to two playoff berths, along with one playoff victory when they won in Pittsburgh during the Covid era.
However, the Browns won just eight games in the last two seasons, including two meaningless games at the end of this season, and Stefanski's offenses struggled badly since the team fired offensive coordinator Alex Van Pelt in an attempt to tailor the offense to the then-starting quarterback, DeShaun Watson.
Stefanski's mantra of "Tough, Smart, and Accountable" slowly frittered away as a team consistently committed stupid penalties ( including Stefanski's final game that saw two touchdowns tagged with excessive celebrations that forced Andre Szymt to make two 49-yard extra points), and generally played undisciplined football and rarely paid any type of price for it.
Stefanski's Achilles heel was his inability to work with quarterbacks, which is confusing considering his arrival from Minnesota was heralded with Stefanski's reputation as a quarterback guru.
Stefanski was unable to revive Baker Mayfield's early success, struggled to connect with DeShaun Watson, his belief in rookie Dillon Gabriel proved to be unfounded, appeared reluctant to give Shedeur Sanders a chance despite Gabriel's struggles, before he was forced to play Sanders after an injury to Gabriel.
Stefanski finished his Browns tenure with a record of 45-56, a record that took a serious dip in his final two seasons after finishing those years with a slate of 8-26.
Stefanski won't be unemployed for very long, as it's been reported that he will interview for at least three teams with head coaching vacancies (Giants, Falcons, and Titans), and was rumored during the season to be the top choice to become the Philadelphia Eagles' offensive coordinator, if he was not hired for a head coaching position.
As for Andrew Berry, the man who built a flawed squad without investing in skilled players to help any of the questionable quarterbacks he provided, he managed to retain his position as general manager due to his first solid draft in the six drafts he oversaw.
While I credit Berry with a solid draft that shines compared to his five previous attempts, with the additions of three or four potential stars (Carson Schwesinger, Harold Fannin, Quinshon Judkins, and Mason Graham), even in that draft, Berry wasted a third rounder on Dillon Gabriel.
Berry has made more errors than I list, even before the DeShaun Watson debacle, with ridiculous extensions to Jerry Juedy and Dustin Hopkins, to name a few, awful drafts that included selecting Jedrick Wills, now out of football, over perennial All-Pro Tristan Wirfs as the Browns' left tackle for the decade, and each time the Browns drafted a wide receiver or offensive lineman, they went bust or below average at best.
Berry drafted Grant Delpit and Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah before the possibly career-ending neck injury to JOK.Outside of those two players, Berry's picks made average to no impact for the Browns.
Berry has especially struggled in picking players at three positions: quarterback, wide receiver, and offensive linemen, which are the team's biggest needs in April's draft, and it gives me anxiety with Berry picking these positions.
I plan a deeper dive into the Andrew Berry-led personnel decisions in the future, but when you consider his picks at quarterback (Dorian Thompson-Robinson, Dillon Gabriel, and Shedeur Sanders), wide receiver (Anthony Schwartz, David Bell, Michael Woods, Cedric Tillman, Jamari Thrash), and offensive line (Jedrick Wills, Nick Harris, James Hudson, Dawson Deaton, Dawand Jones, Luke Wypler, Zac Zinter), it's easy to see my concern.
To be fair, only Jedric Wills was picked in the first two rounds, and some of these picks have been hampered by injury throughout their career, such as Cedric Tillman and Dawand Jones. Berry hasn't been able to land even an average player who starts with consistency at these positions.
When you add in arguably the worst trade in football history, his bungling of the salary cap, and his drafting limitations before 2025, it's fair to question how Berry kept his job.
A narrative of supporters of Kevin Stefanski was that Stefanski deserved the chance to return with his own quarterback, and they often pointed to the lack of offensive talent on the Browns.
The man in charge of building those units was Andrew Berry, and he is being given a mulligan for his mistakes.
I don't feel sorry for Kevin Stefanski. The time was right for him to leave Cleveland.
The problem is that the creator of this roster mess is allowed to stay and continue in his "roster building".
Kevin Stefanski wasn't screwed by losing his job.
Kevin Stefanski was screwed by the Haslams and the Browns, who chose him as the scapegoat as the person most responsible for the disaster that is the Cleveland Browns.
That person kept his job.
I'll be working on the Browns' win over Cincinnati later, and the Andrew Berry deep dive will be coming very soon.
Thanks for reading this extra-long post.