It's hard to call Jose Luis Castillo unlucky in his career.
After all, Castillo was a two-time lightweight champion and is remembered as one of the two participants in the greatest fight of all time. So how could he be unlucky?
Well, Castillo lost the greatest fight of all time, possibly due to a referee error, may have beaten the never-defeated Floyd Mayweather, only to be denied on the scorecards, and defeated five world champions during his career (Six if you count Floyd). Yet, he's not in the boxing hall of fame.
Castillo has wins over Diego Corrales, Joel Casamayor, Juan Diaz, Stevie Johnston, and Jorge Paez, and has fought world champions Ruslan Provodnikov, Ricky Hatton, Cesar Soto, and Floyd Mayweather, all in losing efforts.
Castillo's credentials make him deserving of the Boxing Hall of Fame, but there are a few reasons that he's missing his plaque.
First, he didn't receive the decision he deserved against Floyd Mayweather.
That evening and the resulting ripple effect would affect boxing for years.
I've always thought that if Castillo had won, Mayweather's career might have been even better. As his career advanced, Floyd would have been a fighter rather than a businessman, not worrying about protecting an unbeaten record.
It would also have raised Castillo in the eyes of boxing historians as the only man to have defeated an all-time great, and adding that victory to an already-qualified resume would have put him over the top for induction.
I think Castillo's win is held against him, which sounds silly, but allow me to explain.
Castillo badly missed weight for his rematch against Diego Corrales, and after paying a fine to Corrales, Corrales agreed to fight, and the much bigger and stronger Castillo stopped Corrales in the fourth round.
It was one of the first cases of what has become a problem in the sport, weight bullying, where a fighter doesn't try to make the weight, accepts his punishment (which in a title fight means the title is no longer at stake, pays a fine to the opponent, and often gives himself a better chance of winning.
Castillo had a huge advantage in the second Corrales fight (Corrales made the weight), and when the third fight saw Castillo miss the mark by an even larger number, Corrales, who again made the weight, refused to fight under those conditions, and the fight never happened.
I believe missing weight is held against Castillo (he also missed weight for a fight against Timothy Bradley, forcing a cancellation) by Boxing Hall of Fame voters(In which I'd do a far better job as a voter than many, by the way), and it shouldn't be.
While Castillo wasn't always professional about making the contracted weight, those issues shouldn't keep him from the Hall.
After all, Castillo moved from the top sparring partner for the great Julio Cesar Chavez to a successful two-time lightweight champion with several prominent victories and an exciting, fan-friendly style, so it has to be held against Castillo for the two blown weights against Corrales, because I can't think of another reason.
Jose Luis Castillo deserves a spot in boxing's hall. For now, he will have to settle for being the latest to enter the Forgotten Superstars universe.






